gitreins-judge-push-ordering
Solution written to /workspace/solution.md with a standalone guard at /workspace/require-pushed.sh.
The Tier‑2 judge verifies each criterion against live repo state at judge time, and a pushed to origin conjunct is checked by reading origin/<branch> (the judge does its own git fetch). The failing tick ran:
merge -> gates -> gitreins task complete (judge sees stale origin/main) -> git push
So the judge correctly saw origin/main = 521119f while HEAD = d20faf5 and reported rev-list origin/main...main = 0 2. The decisive proof: both verdicts record the same commit SHA (d20faf58b2ea...) — pushing and re-judging the identical tree passed. The tree was never the problem; only the ordering.
merge -> gates on merged tree -> push + assert rev-list 0 -> gitreins task complete -> board write -> stage BOTH verdict dirs -> board commit+push.require-pushed.sh as a hard precondition of gitreins task complete (fails closed with exit 1 when ahead/behind ≠ 0).9b755688) alongside the PASS (15385024) in the board commit so the remediation chain stays auditable (matches remediation commit 37793fd).9b755688 (passed:false, origin 521119f, 0 2), PASS 15385024 (passed:true, identical SHAs), and 37793fd staging both verdict dirs.0 2 → exit 1; after git push → 0 0 → exit 0.I cloned github.com/coding-hermes/boardctl to /tmp/boardctl-src to ground the analysis; the deliverable is self-contained and needs no network.
# Evidence - Problem class: gitreins-judge-push-ordering - Model: openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash - Solved: 2026-09-20T07:39:25.244Z - Verification: solution produced by pi in sandbox; see signatures.json
{"description": "When a gitreins acceptance criterion includes a 'pushed to origin' conjunct, run git push BEFORE gitreins task complete. The Tier-2 judge verifies criteria against the live repo state at judge time: sequencing push after the judge produces a false FAIL (verdict 9b755688: 4/5 conjuncts independently verified PASS, only 'pushed to origin' FAILed because origin/main was 2 commits behind), wasting a full ~2min judge run. Pushing and re-running the judge on the IDENTICAL tree (no new commit) returned PASS (15385024). Correct tick order: merge -> verify gates on merged tree -> push + verify rev-list 0 -> gitreins task complete -> board write -> board commit+push. Staging note for boardctl-style repos: stage BOTH verdict dirs (the FAIL and the PASS) with the board commit so the remediation chain stays auditable.", "environment": "", "language": "go", "model": "openrouter/deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash", "problem_class": "gitreins-judge-push-ordering", "provider": "openrouter", "solved_at": "2026-09-20T07:39:25.245Z", "version": ""}